Main Content

Back to Blog List

The UPS Store Small Business Blog
  • 20 November 2023
  • Public Relations

How to Check In with Employees with Ease and Effectiveness: Your Go-To Template for Employee Evaluation

In every organization, it is essential to continuously monitor an employee's progress, comfortability in the workplace and their abilities. This ongoing process allows employers to keep a pulse on their workforce and ensure that individuals are thriving in their roles.


Employee evaluations serve as a powerful tool in this regard, providing an opportunity to check in with employees at all levels of the organization. Through these evaluations, employers can provide detailed feedback on job performance, identify areas of improvement and acknowledge exemplary work.

Moreover, conducting regular performance reviews demonstrates to employees that their voices are heard and valued within the organization, resulting in greater retention.

Keep reading our blog post to discover practical tips on constructing an effective performance review template that will benefit both your employees and your organization as a whole.

Why Employee Evaluations Matter

Recognizing the significance of employee evaluations is essential for any organization aiming to maximize its success. These evaluations serve as a powerful management tool, enabling companies to assess and enhance their workforce's performance effectively. Research suggests that organizations conducting effective performance reviews are not only 30 times more likely to meet their financial targets but also three times as likely to navigate through changes successfully.

Performance reviews offer invaluable insights into employees' job performance through detailed feedback and structured evaluation forms. They provide a platform for both supervisors and employees to discuss progress, align expectations and set performance goals. By establishing clear job responsibilities and tracking progress over time, employees gain a better understanding of how their work contributes to the company's overall objectives.

Aside from assessing individual achievements, performance reviews also play a crucial role in fostering professional development. They allow employees to identify areas for improvement and address any skill gaps in order to enhance their professional growth. Furthermore, these evaluations create an opportunity for supervisors and subordinates alike to engage in open dialogue regarding career aspirations and future opportunities within the organization.

Ensuring Engagement and Performance Are Top Tier

It is widely recognized that regular feedback plays a crucial role in enhancing employee performance and engagement. According to studies, employees are found to be three times more engaged when they receive daily feedback from their managers compared to annual feedback sessions.

While it may not be feasible or practical to conduct evaluations every single day, the importance of providing consistent feedback cannot be overstated. Evaluations serve as a means to track and assess an employee's performance against their roles and responsibilities within the organization.

By implementing an effective evaluation process, organizations can ensure that employees are on the same page regarding their job performance expectations. Such evaluations also create opportunities for personal and professional development as they shed light on areas where improvement is needed.

Identify Areas of Improvement

Employee evaluations present a valuable opportunity to recognize and reward the hard work and achievements of your employees. It's a chance to highlight their contributions and show appreciation for their dedication.

Employee evaluations play a crucial role in assessing job performance and providing meaningful feedback to employees. Beyond tracking goals and progress, evaluations also offer an opportunity to gain insights about the overall state of the business. By including questions that touch upon aspects such as workplace inclusivity, diversity and safety, evaluations can help gauge employee perceptions and provide valuable information for company improvement.

This holistic approach to the employee evaluation form and process ensures that employees are not only assessed based on their individual performance but also within a deeper understanding of the organizational culture. Asking employees about their perception of workplace diversity, inclusivity and safety fosters an environment where everyone's voice is heard.

Frequency of Employee Evaluations

When it comes to evaluating employee performance, every manager and business has unique needs and preferences. However, the most common evaluation timelines are monthly, quarterly and yearly. In this section, we will delve into the differences between these three employee evaluation templates and periods to assist you in selecting the right approach for your organization.

It is crucial to note that a large majority of employees, approximately 92%, express a desire for feedback more frequently than just once a year. This highlights the importance of regular feedback in boosting employee engagement and progress.

Monthly Evaluations

In today's fast-paced work environment, where employee engagement and progress are crucial, it has been reported that 32% of employees have to wait more than three months to receive feedback from their managers. This delay can have detrimental effects on employee motivation and growth, as it makes the quarterly or yearly evaluation feel like a disconnected conversation.

Regular employee evaluations play a crucial role in fostering employee engagement and tracking progress. However, conducting full-on evaluations every month can be counterproductive. Instead, implementing a less formal check-in at the beginning or end of each month can provide valuable guidance for employees to achieve successful quarterly or yearly evaluations.

Through these periodic check-ins, employers can inform employees about their performance on both soft skills and technical competencies. This approach ensures that employees have a clear understanding of their strengths, areas for improvement and how they contribute to the overall success of the team.

Creating a structured monthly evaluation process not only aids in measuring individual growth but also enhances the team's performance as a whole. By providing timely feedback and addressing areas where improvement is needed, employers foster an environment where every employee feels supported and motivated to excel.

Quarterly Evaluations

While monthly check-ins provide some insights into an employee's progress, they might not always be sufficient to identify long-term trends or make significant adjustments.

By extending the evaluation period to every three months, or quarterly, organizations can gain a more comprehensive understanding of an employee's performance over a longer duration. This approach allows for a broader perspective on their skill development both in terms of soft expertise and technical skills. It enables managers to observe patterns, track progress and recognize areas for improvement or intervention in a timely manner.

By evaluating performance on a quarterly basis, organizations empower themselves with valuable information to make data-driven decisions regarding training programs, coaching opportunities and future goal-setting discussions. This interval allows sufficient time for employees to demonstrate growth and development while providing ample opportunity for dialogue between managers and employees.

Additionally, quarterly evaluations offer an opportunity to delve deeper into the employee's overall performance and set the stage for annual performance reviews.

Bi-Annual and Yearly Evaluations

While monthly and quarterly reviews offer timely feedback and address immediate concerns, it is equally important to hold longer, comprehensive reviews on a biannual or annual basis.

These longer review periods allow for a more in-depth examination of an employee's overall performance, progress and growth over time. It serves as an opportunity to consolidate the feedback provided in previous reviews and delve deeper into areas that require further attention or improvement.

During these lengthier discussions, managers can take the time to acknowledge points of positive feedback and commend employees for their achievements and contributions. Likewise, any areas for actionable feedback can be addressed more thoroughly, allowing both parties to explore solutions and develop actionable strategies for improvement.

By extending the review period, organizations provide ample opportunity for employees to reflect on their own performance, set goals and align them with company objectives. This process fosters greater engagement and empowers individuals to take ownership of their professional development.

Additionally, longer reviews enable managers to provide more comprehensive performance ratings based on a broader scope of evidence. This holistic approach ensures fairness in evaluating an employee's progress over time rather than relying solely on recent events or isolated incidents.

Elements Needed for a Small Business Employee Evaluation: Your Go-To Template

From beginning to end, evaluating employee performance is an essential aspect of managing a team effectively. Whether it's done annually, quarterly or more frequently, a structured evaluation process ensures that employees understand their job performance and provides an opportunity for open communication and growth.

A crucial component of running an effective evaluation is having the right tools in place. An employee evaluation template serves as a guide, ensuring consistency and fairness in the evaluation process. These evaluation templates should include various sections to assess different aspects of job performance, such as skills, goals and areas for improvement.

When creating your own employee evaluation form template, it's important to customize it to align with your organization's unique goals and values. Consider including sections that evaluate both quantitative and qualitative data.

Evaluation Introduction Template

Before diving into the performance evaluation process, it is important to establish a clear purpose for conducting this evaluation. By clearly outlining the objectives and expectations of the performance evaluation form, you can set a positive tone for the meeting and ensure that both parties are aligned on the desired outcomes.


The first step in this process is to determine what you hope to achieve through the evaluation. Are you looking to assess employee job performance, identify areas of improvement or acknowledge employee progress? By defining these goals upfront, you can tailor your questions and discussion points accordingly.

By setting a positive tone for the evaluation meeting, employees are more likely to feel comfortable discussing their strengths, challenges and aspirations. This sets the stage for constructive feedback and encourages professional growth.

Performance Measures

When evaluating employee performance, it is essential to establish clear and objective metrics to measure their achievements and progress. By focusing on specific performance criteria, employers can gain valuable insights into the effectiveness of their workforce. Some common metrics that can be reviewed during the employee performance review and process include:

  • Meeting Deadlines: Assessing whether employees consistently meet project deadlines showcases their time management skills and ability to prioritize tasks effectively.
  • Overtime Usage: Monitoring the amount of overtime taken by employees can indicate their workload management and potential areas of improvement in workflow efficiency.
  • Goal Attainment: Evaluating how often employees achieve their set goals demonstrates their commitment, dedication and capacity for delivering results within a given time frame.
  • Task Prioritization: Analyzing how well employees prioritize tasks can gauge their ability to organize workloads efficiently and make informed decisions about task importance.
  • Workplace Attitude and Demeanor: Assessing an employee's attitude, professionalism, collaboration skills and overall demeanor in the workplace provides insight into their contribution to a positive work environment.

When conducting performance evaluations, using such objective criteria helps ensure fairness and accuracy in assessing employee performance while providing opportunities for growth and development within the organization.

Main Evaluation Template

Now that we have set the stage with an introduction and outlined what the evaluation will entail, it is time to delve into the heart of the matter.

Employee Self-Assessment

In order to have a holistic and fair evaluation, it is crucial for managers to not only review an employee's work but also seek their perspective on the company's performance management process. This not only promotes a sense of autonomy and ownership in employees but also provides valuable insights that might be missed from a manager's point of view alone.

Employee self-evaluation is an essential component of the overall performance review process. By allowing employees to assess their own accomplishments, strengths and areas for improvement, managers gain a deeper understanding of how employees perceive their own job performance. This self-awareness can lead to more meaningful discussions during the evaluation review and help align expectations between managers and employees.

In order to ensure a fair and comprehensive evaluation of your employees, it can be helpful to ask them the same questions that you ask yourself during the evaluation. This allows for a direct comparison between their self-evaluation and your assessment, giving you valuable insights into any inconsistencies or discrepancies.

Moreover, seeking employee input in evaluating their performance creates an atmosphere of transparency and open communication within the organization. It encourages employees to actively engage in their own development and continuous improvement. When employees feel valued and heard, they are more likely to take responsibility for their actions and strive for higher levels of productivity.

Peer Evaluation Assessment

An effective employee evaluation process goes beyond just the review from the employee and their manager. It is crucial to gather feedback from other employees as well. This additional perspective helps ensure the employee performance review template is a comprehensive and balanced assessment of an employee's job performance.

Feedback from peers can be invaluable in assessing an employee's behavior and their impact on the workplace atmosphere. By confidentially asking how comfortable employees feel around each other, employers can gain insights into the dynamics within the team and identify potential issues that may hinder productivity or create a hostile environment.

An effective employee evaluation should encompass not only the individual's job performance but also their interpersonal and communication skills and ability to contribute to a harmonious work environment. By seeking feedback on comfort levels among colleagues, organizations can address any concerns promptly, intervene where necessary and promote a positive workplace culture where everyone feels valued, respected and safe.

Confidentiality plays a vital role in this process since it encourages honesty from employees who might otherwise hesitate to share their true experiences or raise concerns openly. This approach allows management to address issues proactively while protecting individuals' privacy.

Employee Manager Assessment

When conducting an employee manager assessment, it is crucial to follow certain guidelines to ensure a fair and effective evaluation. By adhering to these practices, managers can accurately assess an employee's job performance and provide valuable feedback for their growth and development.

Firstly, it is essential to compare an employee's performance against their designated role responsibilities. This enables managers to assess whether the employee is meeting, exceeding, or falling short of the expectations set for their position.

To maintain objectivity and clarity in the assessment, it is crucial to use clear and concise language while providing feedback. By avoiding vague or ambiguous statements, managers can offer specific insights into an employee's performance and areas that require improvement.

Peer assessments can also play a valuable role in evaluating employees. Gathering input from colleagues who work closely with the individual being assessed can provide a well-rounded perspective on their behavior and performance within the team or organization.

Beyond simply identifying areas for improvement, constructive feedback is key to helping employees grow professionally. Managers should strive to provide feedback that not only highlights shortcomings but also offers guidance on how employees can enhance their skills and address any identified weaknesses.

To ensure transparency and consistency throughout the evaluation, using a clearly communicated point system can be beneficial. This allows both managers and employees to understand how performance is measured and provides a measurable framework for future evaluations.

Evaluation Closing Template

Closing out an employee evaluation on an actionable and positive note is crucial for the growth and development of both the employee and the organization. It ensures that the insights gained from the employee assessment form are not only informative but also lead to tangible improvements.

Utilizing well-designed employee evaluation forms or free performance review templates can greatly assist in this process. These templates provide a structured approach, allowing evaluators to objectively assess performance based on predetermined criteria. By using consistent evaluation criteria, organizations can ensure fairness and accuracy in their assessments.

Feedback Delivery

When it comes to sharing feedback with your employees as part of the evaluation, it is essential to have a well-thought-out plan for delivering it in a genuine and concise manner. Providing effective feedback is crucial for helping employees understand their performance, identify areas for improvement and set clear performance goals.

Having a clear rating system in place, such as a well-defined rating scale, can provide structure to the evaluation. This allows you to objectively assess employee performance and communicate your observations effectively.

However, it's important to remember that feedback should not solely focus on pointing out performance issues. It should also highlight areas where the employee excels and provide constructive suggestions for continuous improvement.

When it comes to addressing performance issues and fostering continuous improvement in your small business, it is crucial to approach the evaluation with fairness and objectivity. This means taking emotions out of the feedback delivery and focusing on constructive criticism that can lead to real improvements.

Employee evaluation forms provide a structured framework for assessing performance goals and identifying areas that need development. By utilizing these forms, you can ensure a consistent and unbiased evaluation for all employees.

Documentation and Follow-Up

To conduct an effective employee performance evaluation, it is crucial to have a systematic documentation process in place. This ensures that all the points brought up during the employee performance evaluation form are properly recorded and easily accessible for reference.

Using employee performance evaluation forms or templates can be immensely helpful in this regard. These forms provide a structured framework to evaluate employees based on pre-defined criteria and set goals. By utilizing these templates, both the reviewer and the employee being evaluated can have a clear understanding of what areas will be assessed and what expectations need to be met.

Additionally, documenting goals and feedback in a centralized location that is easily accessible to everyone involved is essential. This enables all stakeholders to track progress, follow up on feedback and make necessary updates if needed. Having a well-organized system not only saves time but also ensures consistency in reviewing employee performance over time.

By having an efficient documentation system for evaluations, you create transparency and accountability while facilitating smoother communication between employees and reviewers. Furthermore, it allows for meaningful discussions during future employee performance evaluations if historical data can be easily referenced. Ultimately, this helps foster continuous growth and improvement within the organization.

When it comes to important documents such as employee evaluation forms, it's crucial to have a reliable and efficient printing service. Stop by The UPS Store nearest you for all your printing needs.

Back to Blog List